Cost of Living Comparison Between Brookhaven, NY and New York, NY
For one person, living is cheaper in Brookhaven, NY: $2,882 a month against $4,906 in New York, NY, rent and utilities included – about $24,300 less a year. Rent and utilities account for most of the difference.
-
Brookhaven, NY Living Index134Cost of Living Index in Brookhaven, NYLearn more -
New York, NY Living Index234Cost of Living Index in New York, NYLearn more
How much you'll spend in Brookhaven, NY and in New York, NY
Real prices from locals and on-the-ground checks – rent, groceries, transit and the daily extras. Here's what a month in Brookhaven, NY and in New York, NY actually costs, broken down by who's living it.
Monthly costs for one person with rent: $2,882 in Brookhaven, NY versus $4,906 in New York, NY.
- Brookhaven, NY $2,882
- New York, NY $4,906
Estimated couple costs with rent: $4,227 in Brookhaven, NY versus $7,273 in New York, NY.
- Brookhaven, NY $4,227
- New York, NY $7,273
Monthly costs for a family of three with rent: $5,572 in Brookhaven, NY versus $9,641 in New York, NY.
- Brookhaven, NY $5,572
- New York, NY $9,641
Living in Brookhaven, NY costs roughly 41% less than in New York, NY, and outside of rent the biggest gap is in leisure.
Both cities are pricier than the global median: Brookhaven, NY 113% above, New York, NY 263% above.
CityCost data is based on AI and user input – minor inaccuracies may occur.
Last update for Brookhaven, NY: October 31, 2026
Last update for New York, NY: November 1, 2026
Categories marked with * are only partly priced – their share counts the items that do have prices.
Cost Breakdown
A one-bedroom apartment in the center runs $1,604 in Brookhaven, NY and $4,555 in New York, NY. Housing cost is often the main lever when comparing two cities.
Dining out: $102 in Brookhaven, NY vs $117 in New York, NY for a mid-range dinner for two. Groceries echo the gap at $511 vs $567 per month, with Brookhaven, NY cheaper across the board.
- Brookhaven, NY New York, NY 110 km
- Brookhaven, NY
- New York, NY
Distances are measured in a straight line. Your location is detected approximately.
City Median Internet Speeds Comparison (Updated April 2026)
Is Brookhaven, NY cheaper than New York, NY?
What income do you need for each city?
What is the rent difference between Brookhaven, NY and New York, NY?
Which city has cheaper kindergarten?
How do food prices compare in Brookhaven, NY and in New York, NY?
Is $2,500 enough to cover costs in Brookhaven, NY or in New York, NY?
Is it better to live in Brookhaven, NY or in New York, NY?
Which city is easier to live in as a foreigner?
Brookhaven, NY vs other spots: cost of living compared
Similar cities
Melbourne
Dallas, TX
Las Vegas, NV
Phoenix, AZ
Limassol
The Hague